Should I overpay my mortgage?

As mortgage rates soar, homeowners with spare cash will ask if they should overpay their mortgage, save or invest the money. We outline the different options and which one might be best for you.

Model house, calculator and keys
(Image credit: Getty images)

As mortgage rates soar, homeowners with spare cash may be wondering whether they should try and reduce their mortgage debt. Or is it better to save or invest the money instead? And what about paying it into a pension? 

House price growth is beginning to flatline, and the cost of a mortgage is going up. Many homeowners with a mortgage and some spare cash will be wondering how best to use the money during the current financial turmoil.

Interest rates have hit 2.25% - and are expected to rise further to 5% - while the average two-year mortgage rate has breached 6% for the first time in 14 years.

While homeowners always face an ongoing dilemma about whether to overpay their mortgage, given today’s economic situation, it can feel even more difficult to work out the best course of action.

If you are lucky enough to have some spare money, we look at whether it’s better to overpay the mortgage, squirrel it away in a savings account and take advantage of rising interest rates, invest the money or pay it into a pension.

First, compare your mortgage rate with your savings rate

This is a simple way to work out whether overpaying your mortgage or stashing it in a savings account or cash ISA is the best option.

If your mortgage rate is higher than the rate you’d earn saving, overpaying your mortgage - and therefore reducing the amount of interest you’ll pay - is more effective.

For example, if you have £10,000 in a savings account paying 2% interest, you’ll earn £200 a year. But if you use that £10,000 to overpay a mortgage on a 3% rate, it would reduce your mortgage costs by £300 for the year.

If you took out a mortgage recently, you’re more likely to be on an expensive rate, making it more likely your mortgage rate is higher than the rate you’re earning on your savings. So, overpaying could be the better option.

If you have an older fixed-rate mortgage, it’s probably quite cheap, meaning you may find your savings rate is higher than your mortgage rate - so probably best to keep the money in the savings account.

However, as well as comparing these numbers, think about how you feel about the “overpaying your mortgage” dilemma, and reflect on your own circumstances and financial goals.

Myron Jobson, senior personal finance analyst at interactive investor (opens in new tab), comments: “There isn’t a catch-all answer here. There is a lot to be said about overpaying your mortgage. By paying off your home loan faster, you would reduce the overall interest bill. It also has the psychological benefit of putting you one step closer towards achieving the financial milestone of owning your own home outright.”

How much could you save by overpaying my mortgage?

Your mortgage is likely to be the biggest debt you ever take on, and over the course of the term you’ll be paying thousands of pounds in interest to the lender. 

Overpaying will reduce the amount of interest, and help you pay off the mortgage quicker.

For example, someone who borrowed £200,000 over the course of a 25-year mortgage would pay £948 a month, assuming an interest rate of 3%.

If you overpaid by £200 a month, you’d save £21,620 in interest and reduce your mortgage term by six years.

For someone with the same £200,000 mortgage, but a 6% interest rate, overpaying by £100 a month means you'd save £32,017 in interest and reduce your mortgage term by four years.

Have a look at how much you could save by using our mortgage overpayment calculator.

If you are planning to overpay your mortgage…

If it makes sense to overpay your mortgage, make sure you check a few things first:

  1. Do you have other debts like credit cards or personal loans? If these are more expensive than your mortgage rate, use your spare cash to clear them first. 
  2. Have you got an easy-access emergency cash fund? It’s wise to have a pot of money that you can dip into in case you lose your job or have a large unexpected expense, like paying for a new boiler. Aim to have three to six months’ worth of bills saved before overpaying your mortgage.
  3. Are there any overpayment penalties? Many lenders let you overpay up to 10% of your mortgage balance each year. Go above this level and you could be hit with some steep penalties. Check your mortgage balance online or give your lender a call to check how much you can overpay penalty-free.
  4. Make sure each overpayment reduces the mortgage term and not your future repayments. You may need to speak to your lender to ensure this happens. That way, you’ll benefit from cutting the amount of interest you owe and becoming mortgage-free quicker.
  5. Regularly compare your mortgage rate and savings rate, especially if there’s a big movement with either of them. You may find that one option suddenly becomes more attractive, and you should switch what you’re doing with your spare cash.

If you are planning to save the money…

As long as your emergency savings pot of money is in place, and you’re confident saving the extra cash is a better option than overpaying your mortgage, the next thing to do is find a competitive savings rate.

Here’s our round-up of the best cash ISAs and best savings accounts.

Jobson notes: “If you find a savings account offering a rate of interest that is higher than that applied on your mortgage, there is also the added benefit of being able to access the cash more easily if needed. Because once a mortgage overpayment is made, you normally lose access to that money.”

However, there are other options besides saving the money. You could also invest it, or pay it into your pension.

According to Rob Morgan, chief investment analyst at the wealth manager Charles Stanley (opens in new tab), what you do with your spare cash really depends on personal circumstances, your age, the terms of the mortgage and the interest rate, “and, very importantly, whether you are a risk-taker or more risk-averse”.

Is investing the money a smart decision?

Investing the money instead of overpaying your mortgage or putting it in a savings account could be a better choice IF your investments outperform both the savings rate and the mortgage.

So, if you invest your money for a year and achieve a 7% return, this will have been a smarter move than overpaying a mortgage with a 2.5% rate, or receiving 3.5% in savings interest.

“Although investing may generate higher returns than a mortgage's interest cost or keeping your money in a cash ISA, markets also come with the risk of losses. That uncertainty is a factor in itself,” notes Morgan.

“It comes down to priorities and, quite possibly, how different routes make you feel.”

Jobson agrees: “The key difference is mortgage overpayments offer certainty on how much you would save in interest payments on your loan. Whereas the catch with investing is that returns are not guaranteed.”

You may prefer the peace of mind of reducing your mortgage interest and paying off the debt faster compared to worrying about the performance of financial markets and the potential advantages of investing. 

Having said that, over the long term investing has a good track record of beating savings account returns. If you’re happy to take on some risk, investing your spare cash could be a better choice.

What about paying the money into a pension?

One factor that might tilt the balance in favour of investing over paying down your mortgage is if you can get a significant bonus on your money. 

Pensions are a great investment scheme in this regard, as tax relief can give your returns a big boost.

Basic-rate tax relief, for instance, adds 25% to the value of your pot, and for higher-rate taxpayers there is an even larger boost. If you have access to a workplace pension, your employer will pay in too, making it a really cost-effective method to save for retirement. 

Morgan comments: “This should be maximised to the greatest extent possible before investing elsewhere.”

According to Morgan, some investors pay more into their pension and then use that money to help pay off their mortgage later - but remember that you can’t access that money until age 55 (rising to 57 in 2028). “Bear in mind too that pension rules, and tax relief, can change in the future,” he adds.

Morgan concludes that if the homeowner’s broader finances are in good shape – they don’t have other high-interest debts to pay off and they have built up a fund for emergencies of around six months’ expenditure – both strategies of overpaying your mortgage and investing (whether in a stocks and shares ISA or a pension) can work well.

Ruth Emery is contributing editor at The Money Edit. Ruth is passionate about helping people feel more confident about their finances. She was previously editor of Times Money Mentor, and prior to that was deputy Money editor at The Sunday Times. A multi-award winning journalist, Ruth started her career on a pensions magazine at the FT Group, and has also worked at Money Observer and Money Advice Service. Outside of work, she is a mum to two young children, a magistrate and an NHS volunteer.