What do insurers think about e-cigarettes?
Will your insurer class you as a smoker if you vape? We find out
- (opens in new tab)
- (opens in new tab)
- (opens in new tab)
- Sign up to our newsletter Newsletter

Truly, we live in the future – a time where people can charge their electronic cigarettes using the redundant lighter point in their car.
But what do health insurance and life insurance companies think of this new way to feed a nicotine addiction?
After all, the World Health Organisation has just called for a ban on using the hi-tech cigarettes in public places – so surely insurers must take a dim view as well?
Are e-cigs healthier?
Professor Robert West, of University College London’s department of epidemiology and public health, recently headed a study into e-cigarettes and found that they dramatically improve people’s chances of quitting – although not as much as seeking out NHS stop-smoking services.
However, even he couldn’t be sure what the long-term results could be – although he did seem pretty optimistic: “It is not clear whether long-term use of e-cigarettes carries health risks but from what is known about the contents of the vapour these would be much less than from smoking.”
Yet some countries and US states have gone so far as to ban or heavily control e-cigarettes, suggesting that the jury is still out on their safety.
Do insurers consider you a smoker if you vape?
As it stands, insurers are reluctant to treat vaping any differently to smoking. If you apply for a life insurance policy then you’ll be asked about your nicotine intake, whether through cigs or e-cigs.
Russell Whitworth, claims and underwriting director at Legal & General, gave us the insurance industry’s typical view: “We do treat e-cigarette users as ‘normal’ smokers as the vast majority of the users remain addicted to nicotine. This is generally accepted practice in the industry but we continue to monitor as the situation is reviewed over time.”
This is a rapidly developing market and it’s not yet clear what the long-term effects of vaping – if any – could be. But e-cigarettes complicate underwriting insurance even more than that.
Michael Whyte, underwriter for Aviva, explains: “When e-cigarettes were originally introduced they were marketed as smoking cessation aids and as such it would have been considered unlikely that anyone using them would not have also used tobacco products within the last 12 months.”
Most insurers require at least a year without smoking before they regard the customer as a non-smoker. After all, there’s a strong chance they'll relapse.
Another issue for insurers is proving customers’ claims. At the moment, if you apply for life insurance and say you’re a non-smoker then they might test you for nicotine. But if you’re vaping then you will have nicotine in your system, and it’s impossible for the insurer to know if that’s from tobacco - which is definitely harmful - or vaping, which may or may not be harmful.
So you can see why most insurers have a blanket approach to vaping.
Health insurance companies take a slightly different view on smoking to life insurance. While most, if not all, health insurers class e-cig use as smoking, very few health insurers actually price smokers and non-smokers differently.
To quit or not to quit?
So, are e-cigs simply a new way to get a nicotine fix, or are they a way to stop smoking? Certainly some people are using them as quitting aids. But others make the switch from real cigs and then stick with their new, apparently cleaner habit.
So e-cigarettes may feel like a cleaner, healthier choice but, for now at least, insurers still aren’t convinced.
Felicity is a freelance print and broadcast journalist, specialising in consumer affairs and personal finance. Her work appears regularly in the Independent, Mirror, Sunday Times and on the BBC News website. She is also the personal finance reporter for BBC Radio 5 Live’s Wake Up To Money show. On top of that, she is a frequent reporter and commentator for many other programmes and stations, including Radio 4’s Money Box, Sky News and BBC Radio Wales.
-
-
New NS&I Green Savings Bonds three-year fixed-rate of 4.20% - is it worth it?
Eco-friendly savers can get more now that NS&I has increased the interest rate paid by its flagship green savings bond
By Katie Binns • Published
-
Prepayment meter energy vouchers worth millions of pounds unclaimed - how to get yours
380,000 energy vouchers were left unclaimed by households on prepayment meters, Post Office data reveals
By Vaishali Varu • Published
-
Revealed: the job titles that add £100s to car insurance - and the cheaper alternatives
Job titles that will see the biggest rise in car insurance costs in 2023 have been revealed - is your job title one of them? And how to find cheaper alternatives
By Vaishali Varu • Published
-
How to avoid sneaky car insurance fees
Some motor insurers are increasing fees and charges for motorists. We reveal how to avoid them
By Sue Hayward • Published
-
How to get cheap car insurance: 10 ways to cut the cost
If you’re a driver, you can’t hide from paying for car insurance but knowing how to get cheap car insurance can cut the cost without compromising cover quality.
By Vaishali Varu • Published
-
Amazon sells insurance: is comparing and buying an insurance policy through Amazon any good?
Amazon Insurance Store launches in the UK to sell home insurance
By Sue Hayward • Published
-
Life insurance: the risks and cost of cancelling your cover
If you’ve got life insurance but can no longer afford monthly payments – what are your options?
By Sue Hayward • Published
-
How to save on your home insurance and get the best deal
Home insurance is crucial protection but can be expensive. We highlight the ways to still enjoy the same level of cover but at a lower price
By John Fitzsimons • Published
-
8 mistakes that could invalidate your travel insurance
You don’t want to go to the effort of buying travel insurance and then find it doesn’t pay out when making a claim - we highlight some common mistakes to avoid
By Katie Binns • Published
-
Average home insurance premiums drop to record low - is now the time to switch?
Households get some “cost of living relief” as buildings and contents insurance prices fall
By Ruth Emery • Last updated