E.on raised my energy direct debit from £42 to £116 a month - how I fought back, and how you can too

Is your energy company playing fair? Here’s what The Money Edit’s Guy Anker did when his energy company almost tripled his monthly payment

lady disputing her bills over the phone
(Image credit: getty images)

The latest energy price cap means households are already paying an average of 54% more for their gas and electricity, but are energy companies taking the opportunity to unfairly hike your bills? If so, it’s time to fight back, writes Guy Anker.

We can’t control the soaring cost of energy which is crippling so many households’ budgets, with some forced into the awful position of having to choose between heating and eating. 

However, what we can control to some degree is the amount we are billed if we pay by monthly direct direct, and with many energy firms overcharging customers there’s ample reason to fight back.

If you pay by this method - which in fact gets you the cheapest rates - then your energy firm is effectively estimating what you will use on an annual basis and dividing it by 12.

If it’s wrong then you are either entitled to a rebate or you need to repay the difference, though often any arrears or overpayments are dealt with by adjusting your next year’s direct debits accordingly.

Many firms are overcharging 

Since energy prices jumped for most of us in April, energy firms have had to raise direct debit payments, but many have been caught putting them up way too much, arguably taking advantage of a difficult situation for many. 

In fact, the energy regulator Ofgem is investigating and some firms could be fined as a result. They have until next week to respond to Ofgem’s concerns.

But you don’t have to wait for Ofgem to intervene - if your increase is unreasonable, then let your provider know.

I am one of those likely overcharged. I used to pay £42 a month for my electricity-only tariff to E.on, but it wrote to me earlier this year to say that was going up to £116 a month, almost three times as much, despite the fact the average rise in bills was 54% in April.

Of course, as that’s only an average, some people’s bills will go up by more or less than 54% but I thought my hike was ridiculous.

So I did a ‘back of an envelope’ calculation using the underlying charges for my tariff and I thought it should have gone up to £69 a month.

That’s still a huge rise but nothing like paying more than £100 a month. I can’t be certain I’ve got that right but I’d put a bet on the fair figure being closer to my estimate than E.on’s. 

How I fought back and how you can too 

I sent E.on an email at the end of February and to be fair to it, I had a reply a day later agreeing to my request to pay £69 a month instead.

That tale is one I hope can inspire others, as you have a right to ask for a fair direct debit that accurately reflects your likely usage. 

It is as simple as asking, whether by email, phone, app or online chat, depending on your firm’s communication options. 

This is about cashflow and money management rather than the underlying charge, as if your direct debit is too low or too high then it will eventually get evened out. So in my case, if the mistake was mine then I will have to pay back the difference eventually. 

But at a point when money is tight for so many, if your energy firm has hiked your direct debit by too much, then fighting to get something back in your monthly budget could make a big difference to your bank balance.

Guy Anker
Guy Anker

Guy has extensive experience in personal finance journalism having joined The Money Edit after 13 years at MoneySavingExpert.com, most recently as deputy editor, and working closely alongside Martin Lewis. 

He has also worked at the Daily Mail as a personal finance reporter and his work has appeared in The Sun, Guardian, Observer, Mirror and other national newspapers. 

As a money and consumer expert, Guy is a regular guest on TV and radio – appearing on BBC News, BBC Radio 4, Sky News, ITV News and more. 

Guy also often speaks at events and appears on personal finance discussion panels. He has also been a judge for numerous industry awards. 

When he is not working on helping the public save money, he thinks he's a good bargain-hunter, whether by haggling on his broadband bill or spending hours researching the cheapest hotels for family holidays. But he's less good with his money when it comes to football, witnessed by the £1,400 he shells out each year on his Arsenal season ticket.